美元为什么还没倒?

摘要

美元体系的生存需要具备三要素:

1)外国金融资本持续流入美国
2)保持汇率波动可控
3)保证通胀稳定

这三点是美元的生命线,一个也不能少。美元的生命不仅要依赖时常抽风的金融市场来保障,还要依赖以中国为龙头的新兴国家的资金供养和廉价商品的稳定供应,没有外汇储备国的双重喂养,美元就无法稳定。美联储唯一的办法是利用利率工具和忽悠来驱动金融资本朝着对美元有利的方向走。如果忽悠无效,美联储开动印钞机,就等于把美元这艘大船往冰山上撞。

一句话:美元的生存体系靠双重喂养和美联储忽悠,美元的生命线握在亚洲手中,如果亚洲决意不再供养美元,美联储忽悠失效,美国政府和美联储能有什么工具来保护美元?

中华民族伟大复兴的最大障碍就是美国,美国实力依赖美元。美元倒了,美国的科技实力和军事实力都成了无源之水、无木之本。我的两篇论文从理论和真实的市场两个角度论证了美元根本不可怕。美元的小命就攥在我们手心里。我们要有勇气切断供养美元的脐带, 充满自信的踏上民族复兴之路!

一,国际收支平衡原理恒等式的威力

今天我重点从市场角度分析美元为什么至今还没有倒下。从市场角度分析美元还是不能离开国际收支平衡原理,再重申一下这个恒等式:

经常项余额=金融项余额+外汇储备

经常项余额:来自贸易顺逆差和海外利润及资金调转的流动。

外汇储备:国家储备的外币资产。中国的外汇储备主要来自贸易顺差,日本的外汇储备主要来自海外利润回流,瑞士的外汇储备则来自对冲国际金融资本流入对本国汇率的冲击。

金融项余额:银行和金融资本的流进流出。

为什么国际收支平衡原理恒等式不可颠覆?因为这个公式就像会计原理一样永远起作用。有资金来源才有资金占有,这个原理100%制约着国际收支。不论美元是国际结算货币,还是人民币不是自由流通货币,在这个平衡原理面前大家是平等的。以为美元是国际储备货币就可以印钞买全世界资产完全是幻觉!在国际收支平衡原理管束下,国际贸易支出一定要用国际贸易收入来填平,没有支付能力,就转为外债。所以,现行国际贸易体系还是易货贸易的变种。贸易不平衡,外债填。

之前25讲,我从理论上论证了美联储为什么不能印钞还债,这一理论其实并不复杂:

尽管美国欠的是美元本币债,但如果美联储开动印钞机还债,债权国还是要卖出美元。大家一定要记住:国际外汇市场交易永远是一买一卖同步的两个动作。就是说,如果你要卖出一种货币,必须同步买入等值的另一种货币;如果你要买入一种货币,必须同步卖出等值的另一种货币。抛美债是这样一个程序:美债以美元计价,中国抛美债必须先卖出美债,拿到美元,这是第一步。中国卖美债换回美元,美联储手里有美元,美联储可以接这笔美债。但中国只抛美债没有意义,等于把美债和美元外汇储备做了一个置换。真要抛美债,必须卖出美债换回美元后,再卖出这笔美元换回等值的其它货币才算真正抛美债,这是第二步。这也是我为什么经常说抛美债同时必须抛美元。这样,如果美联储印钞还债给中国,美联储买入美债,中国卖出美债,体现在外汇交易上,最终就是中国卖出1万亿美元买入等值其它货币。这时问题就来了,中国卖出美元,谁来买入美元?如果美联储买入美元,美联储卖出什么货币?美国的外汇储备几乎是零,美联储无法卖出一个自己没有的非美元货币!看:国际收支原理就这么简单!美联储没有任何外汇储备,当他国卖出美元,美联储根本无法干预汇市!无法干预汇市,市场卖出的美元就找不到买家;找不到美元的买家,美元汇率不就崩盘了吗?这就是为什么我总是说:美元没有任何自我保护力,美元是不折不扣的裸奔。美元稳定与否完全取决于国际债权人对美元的信心,信心崩塌时,除了债权人,上帝也帮不了美国。

以上论点,至今还没有遇到任何有效质疑和挑战,尽管很多经济学家和金融圈完全不接受我的结论。

面对经济学家的疑惑,我发现了一个很奇特的现象:我们的经济学家把西方经济学神化了。大家习惯性地认为美联储有无限印钞能力,美国的债务可以开动印钞机来还。因此,当我论证美联储无法印钞还债,学者们懵了,完全提不出有效的学术质疑!

过去200年,西方经济学理论基本没有遇到像样的挑战,学者们困在西方教科书的思维框架中,失去了独立思考能力。更让我意外的是很多经济学家从未研究过国际收支数字并认真分析这些数字内在的经济关系!

一个国家的国际收支能力就像企业的现金流,是国家的生命线。国际收支能力不仅影响到汇率定价,还影响本国的货币政策和国家财政开支的可持续性,更事关国家的印钞能力。在纸币时代,印钞能力是国家救治金融危机的最后防线!国家的印钞机坏了,国家的金融安全就被不可预期的金融市场左右。想要看清全球经济的真相,必须好好研究国际收支平衡。

金融圈也没有认真思考我的论证逻辑。他们普遍认为,我严重低估了美联储对全球金融市场的把控能力。可当我问他们:请你告诉我,当市场对美元信心崩塌时,美联储有什么工具可以保护美元?却没一个人能拿出救市方案。但他们就是相信美元死不了!金融圈精英把全球金融市场对美元的支持当成上帝之手了!反正上帝会保护美国,不用杞人忧天!

我突然发现自己面对的不是经济学和金融精英的思考视角,而是经济学和金融市场这两个神学!在神学面前,逻辑与事实都显得苍白无力!信仰不需要证据!

二,从市场角度看为什么美元至今不倒?

尽管金融圈想不出美联储拿什么工具来稳定美元,他们还是提出了一些金融现象层面的问题。我是职业投资人,对货币问题的思考全部来自对市场的跟踪和数据分析,今天我就从市场角度回答一些金融圈的问题。

总结一下大家的问题:

1)巴菲特2003年就警告说:长期贸易逆差,美国将沦为债权人的殖民地。其实巴菲特就是告诉美国人,美国贸易逆差导致的外债只能靠贸易顺差来还。只是巴菲特没有直接说出来美国不能印钞还债而已。 大家的问题是,美元这么大的问题,为什么美元今天仍然很强?

2)你说全球外汇储备见顶是美元即将寿终正寝的信号,且从2015年开始,外国投资人就停止追加美债,那为什么美债市场仍然很稳定?

3)你说美联储不能印钞还债,为什么2008年美联储QE,美元不但没有贬值还升值了?

截止2019年9月,美国的国际收支余额为:总资产28万亿,总负债39万亿,净负债11万亿,美国是个不折不扣的无本经营的国家。美国持有外国总资产28万亿,持有这28万亿资产的资金来源是总负债39万亿。也就是说,美国利用美元国际储备货币的地位开世界银行,向全世界借债39万亿,买了全球资产28万亿,资不抵债11万亿。只要全球还愿意源源不断借钱给美国去填美元债务黑洞,美元就可以续命。相信美元无可替代、战无不胜没有任何事实依据,只是一个信仰而已。

持续增加外债要依赖金融资本对美元的信心。光有信心还不够,金融机构还必须有足够的水源供给才行,池子里有水,华尔街才能把全球储蓄搬运到美元,从而使美元得到源源不断的债务供养。

国际收支平衡原理决定了美国有多少逆差就需要多少外国资本的流入来填充,但在多边金融体系下,金融资本的流动由利益和风险驱动,逆差国不一定就有稳定的资本流入来补充,一旦流入资金链断裂,货币危机就来了。这就是为什么南美货币危机和金融危机此起彼伏。

所以,不论是全球外汇储备来供养美国,还是全球金融资本来供养美国,都是国家间的储蓄搬家。全球外汇储备供养是政府用国家行为把本国贸易盈余攒下的储蓄搬到美国,金融资本供养是在利益驱动下把本国百姓的储蓄直接搬到美国。当然,这种储蓄搬家表现在账面上就是美国的外债。

通过对数字的长期观察,我发现金融资本搬家的总水源来自全球外汇储备。外汇储备和经常项顺差对冲,而美国外债沉重的根源则是经常项逆差。理论上,金融资本与外汇储备正好是阴阳一对儿。

让我们在这个平衡原理指导下看看金融资本流动的实际数字。(附件1:美国经常项累计与全球外汇储备对比)

我把美国的经常项逆差、全球外汇储备、美元汇率的变化放在同一个表格上,这时一个奇妙的“巧合”出现了。美元指数的涨跌和全球外汇储备与美国经常项逆差之间的差额有一个完美的契合!就是说,当全球外汇储备不能覆盖美国经常项逆差时,美元是贬值的!全球外汇储备见顶而美国贸易逆差不见顶是美元的危险信号,这就是市场角度的佐证!全球外储和美国经常项之间的关系有力的证明了美国长期增加借债而美元还没有崩塌的一个原因。

三,美联储能继续用QE给美元续命吗?

上面是宏观论证,现在从微观市场角度来看看为什么2008年美联储QE,美元没有贬值还升值了?(附件2,1990- 2008年美元指数图,把美元指数定格时间到2008。)

看美元升值和贬值压力,长期要看供养美元债务的水源是不是充足。短期要看投机和投资资本的流动趋势。

我们把时间锁定2008年,看看为什么2008年金融危机,美联储QE,美元没有贬值反而升值了?看图表,美元从2001年开始走贬值周期,贬值趋势一直到次贷危机前的2007年,6年贬值幅度达40%。危机来了,避险模式启动,美元长期空头平仓盘成为美元买盘的主动力。市场中所谓的避险行为就是投资人了结现有投资部位的举动。之前美元是空头趋势,很多投机资本做空美元,危机来了,美元空头的避险动作就变成买入美元。这就是为什么2008年金融危机,美联储QE,美元没有贬值反而结束了贬值趋势的市场原因。

结论:2008年美联储QE,美元没有贬值反而升值,短期是美元空头回补,中期是因为全球外汇储备的增长大于美国逆差的增幅。

关于美联储能不能印钞还债的市场论证,最重要的是要明白抑制美联储印钞还债的技术障碍是印钞对美元汇率稳定性的挑战。自由流通的货币都是一币两用,美联储印钞没有流出美国,就不会影响国际收支平衡,不影响国际收支平衡,也就不会影响汇率稳定。对自由流动的货币来说,你很难控制资金的流出。央行印钞买资产对市场有挤出效应,这个挤出效用在欧元上体现得很充分。这就是为什么欧元一直很弱,尽管欧元区是贸易顺差,但欧洲央行从2015年开始一直定期定量购买金融资产。(附件3: 欧洲央行QE和欧元区经常项顺差)2015年到2018年,欧洲央行QE累计2.4万亿欧元,同期欧洲顺差1.4万亿欧元。尽管欧洲央行没有进入市场卖出欧元买入美元来增加欧元区的外汇储备,但欧洲央行购买欧洲金融资产,对金融资本有挤出效应,使得欧洲金融资本流出欧元,买了更多的美元。2015年之后,全球外汇储备增速见顶,是欧洲金融资本进入美元,维持了美元的供养体系。

这时问题就来了,欧元区能不能替代亚洲长期来供养美元?回答这个问题要看欧洲有没有余粮长期供应给美国。

截止2018年底,欧元区国际收支总资产25万亿美元,总负债也是25万亿美元,这证明了欧洲自己并没有余粮。欧元区对美元资产的增持,宏观上看,其资金来源于全球外汇储备的多元化。主权国家对美元开始有戒心,资金流向欧洲,欧洲资金又流向美元。这就是为什么我说:中国卖美元买其他货币根本不能阻断美元风险。要规避美元风险,就必须勇于挑起担子,建立全新的货币体系。经济全球化把我们拴成一个金融生命共同体,美元出了问题,谁也别想全身而退!

这时有人会说:美元是本币债,美联储印钞,大不了就是美元贬值呗,美元贬值等于减轻美国债务,对美国有利啊!对,美元贬值可以减轻美国的债务负担,但是,美国消费品依赖进口,美元贬值会拉动进口商品涨价,通胀将是压死美元的泰山。一旦美国通胀失控,35万亿的外国国际金融资产一定会落荒而逃,美国一夜沦为阿根廷一点也不是神话。

这时问题又来了:2001-2007美元贬值40%,美国也没有通胀啊?

2000年是中国融入全球化的元年,人民币和美元软挂钩,中国和亚洲廉价产品源源不断流入美国,稳定了美国通胀。现在人民币和美元脱钩,当美元贬值周期再次到来,人民币对美元也将升值。如今中国已经不是廉价劳动力资源国,亚洲产能又无法替代中国的供应总量,可以预见,这次美元贬值周期到来时,美国通胀就无法淡定了。看美国从中国进口的规模,也佐证了美国能通胀稳定,中国功不可没。(附件4: 美国自中国进口1991-2008)

1991年到1999年,美国从中国累计进口4176亿美元,2000年到2008年则累积进口1.87万亿美元,后9年是前9年的4.47倍! 这就是2001-2007年美元贬值周期美国通胀稳定的压舱石!中国和亚洲不仅购买美债,还给美国提供了源源不断的廉价商品,这种双重供养,才是美元得以生存的土壤。

再来看一张图,美元指数和通胀的关系(附件5美元指数和CPI对比

在80年代之前,美元和通胀是联动的,美元贬值,通胀上升;美元升值,通胀下滑。80年代之后,美元指数波动相对减弱,美国通胀也不随美元指数波动了。想想看,80年代之后世界经济格局发生了什么变化?先是日本腾飞,然后是四小龙,2000年之后则是中国国际贸易量猛增,再加上中国巨大的基本建设投资拉动了石油和原材料需求。推动了石油和原材料供应国的贸易改善,这些国家大幅度增加了外汇储备。所以,无可争辩的事实证明美元的供养来源是亚洲和原材料产出国,而原材料产出国的繁荣是中国需求拉动的。一句话,2000年后,美元的生存是中国直接和间接供养的。美元至今还活得滋润,通胀还稳定,就是中国还没有路径去美元,还没有找到去美元的顶层设计!中国是美国的双重供养者,也是美元生存的巨大威胁。美元汇率和通胀稳定的生杀大权都握在中国手里,期望中央能及早认识到这一点!

  四,我们只欠一个决心

中国的外汇储备见顶,原材料价格又决定了石油和原材料供应国的外汇储备见顶,(附件6: 石油价格图)(附件7: 原材料价格指数图)全球外汇储备也见顶,美国的贸易逆差即便见了顶也还是逆差。每年的逆差累计存量转化为美国的对外总借债,即便美国的逆差不再增长,美国也没有可能实现贸易平衡。因此,美国的外债问题永远是美国经济安全的一个不定时炸弹!

美国专家分析,1970年开始,美国的国际收支一直是负流水。2000年之前是石油需求和日本奇迹支持美元,2000年之后是以中国为龙头的亚洲产业链收入供养美国。现在中国和亚洲的供养能力见顶,中国也不愿意继续供养美国,而要投资一带一路,那当今世界能找到一个有中国体量和供应能力的新经济体继续供养美国吗???如果没有,美元怎么办???

总结:美元体系的生存需要具备三要素:

1)外国金融资本持续流入美国
2)保持汇率波动可控
3)保证通胀稳定

这三点是美元的生命线,一个也不能少。美元的生命不仅要依赖时常抽风的金融市场来保障,还要依赖以中国为龙头的新兴国家的资金供养和廉价商品的稳定供应,没有外汇储备国的双重喂养,美元就无法稳定。美联储唯一的办法是利用利率工具和忽悠来驱动金融资本朝着对美元有利的方向走。如果忽悠无效,美联储开动印钞机,就等于把美元这艘大船往冰山上撞。

一句话:美元的生存体系靠双重喂养和美联储忽悠,美元的生命线握在亚洲手中,如果亚洲决意不再供养美元,美联储忽悠失效,美国政府和美联储能有什么工具来保护美元?

中华民族伟大复兴的最大障碍就是美国,美国实力依赖美元。美元倒了,美国的科技实力和军事实力都成了无源之水、无木之本。我的两篇论文从理论和真实的市场两个角度论证了美元根本不可怕。美元的小命就攥在我们手心里。我们要有勇气切断供养美元的脐带,充满自信的踏上民族复兴之路!

马霞

2020.2.21

附件1:美国经常项累积和全球外汇储备对比

附件2,1990- 2008年美元指数图

附件3: 欧洲央行QE和欧元区经常项顺差

附件4: 美国自中国进口1991-2008

附件5: 美元指数和CPI对比

附件6: 石油价格图

附件7: 原材料价格指数图

美元困局和世界人民元

美元的困局和世界人民元内容提要:

这篇7000字论文我是写给国内有关部门的,全篇力求用事实来展示美元的问题,揭示西方经济学的幼稚可笑。

经济学是解决问题的学问,我以问题为导向,总结亚洲国家在过去20年的实践经验,提出来我的世界人民元的解决方案。

中华民族伟大复兴的最大阻碍来自美国,而美元是最大的栏路虎。美元一旦失去信用,美国的军事实力和科技实力都将成为无水之源、无本之木。砍掉美国这个大旗, 台湾香港问题根本都不是问题!砍倒了美元这个大旗,西方经济学才能显出可笑幼稚的原形。我们才能在世界上真正拥有话语权!美元问题是世界经济的毒瘤,摘掉这个毒瘤中国才能为全球化续命,为人类命运共同体铺路!期望中央能早做打算!

这篇文章是我长期研究的核心观点,文字数量有限,不能全面展开。想深入了解,可以到喜马拉雅搜索“马姐谈投资”。

让我们共同努力,战胜美元!期望读者把我的论文上达天听!

我从事国际贸易和外汇交易30年,真金白银在市场上拼杀,并一直思考经济全球化在国际清算层面的技术障碍。国际收支平衡原理决定了贸易顺差国拥有贸易逆差国的债权,在多边自由贸易体系下这个清算难题就变得异常复杂。

国际收支平衡原理:

经常项余额=金融项余额+外汇储备

国际收支平衡原理决定了,等式左边是逆差,等式右边就是对外欠债。等式左边是顺差,等式右边就是国际金融债权。逆差国是无法对顺差国实现清偿的。不管美元是国际清算货币,还是人民币不是一个自由流动货币,其国际收支平衡原理是一样的。国际贸易是两次清算,一次是贸易商之间的清算,另一次是不同国家之间的货币转换清算。即便美国用美元在全世界交易,但美国的外债还是外债,拥有国际贸易清算货币地位的美元同样无法逾越国际收支平衡原理的约束。这就是为什么巴菲特说:长期贸易逆差,美国将沦为债权人的殖民地!

这是西方经济学300年来没有解决的难题。三年前,我终于找到破解的方案,这套解决方案完全从技术出发,并且用2017年的真实数字做了沙盘推演,实践证明是完全行得通的。希望能呈报给中央,为美元霸权退出历史舞台提供有效的技术解决方案!

我的报告从美元问题入手,一步步推出世界人民元替代美元的终极方案。

(一)美元困局

看美国人主导的全球化和他们自己设计的美元体系,对美国是有利还是有害?需要从《国际收支平衡表》入手(见附件1: 美国《国家收支平衡表》)

国际收支平衡原理:

经常项余额=金融项余额+外汇储备
 
从1960年算起,美国累积贸易和服务逆差11.5万亿美元,国际投资净收入3.27万亿美元,个人汇出+政府的国际开支2.37万亿美元。这就是说,在过去59年,美国企业累计全球利润回流减去对外国投资者的利润返还,总共净赚了3.27万亿美元。这块收入减去政府的海外开支2.37万亿美元,非贸易类净收入9000亿美元,而这9000亿收入根本无法覆盖11.5万亿的贸易逆差!因此,美国整个国家的运营就靠不断增加外债来维系。过去59年累积增加外债11万亿美元!公众普遍认为尽管美国在贸易上是逆差,但是美国的企业在全球化中赚翻了,这个说法是完全没有事实根据的。

事实是,美国经营的以美元为核心的国际货币体系是以美国不断增加外债来维系的。 截止2019年9月,全球外汇储备11万亿美元,美国的净外债也是11万亿美元,如果站在全球角度看,全球外汇储备都填了美国的债务黑洞!美元这个庞氏骗局就快穿帮了!

美国这么显而易见的问题,为什么没有引起全球警惕呢?因为主流经济学家认为,这就是特里芬悖论决定的。那什么是特里芬悖论呢?

(二)荒谬的特里芬悖论

特里芬认为,承担外债是美元成为储备货币的必要条件。货币在全球自由流动,贸易顺差国的储蓄自然流向了贸易逆差国,因为顺差国金融机构如果不收购出口商卖出的美元,出口商的再生产就无法持续进行。从而贸易顺差国拥有对贸易逆差国的金融债权,贸易逆差国就不断的积累欠债。特里芬先生认为,储备货币国要吸纳全球储蓄,自然只有贸易逆差国才有外债的需求,从而才能成为全球储备货币。因此,像中国和日本这样的贸易顺差国就天然不能成为储备货币国。这就是所谓的特里芬悖论。称之为悖论,因为每个人都知道逻辑不通!我们的世界就是这么荒谬!关系到全球金融稳定的大问题,其理论基础竟然出自一个悖论!在这个悖论支持下,美国的外债越垒越高。全世界人民的储蓄都只能去填美国的债务黑洞!

公众对美国的外债问题没有足够的警醒,还因为大家普遍认为美国大不了赖债呗!

(三)如果美国赖债…?

美国到底能不能赖债?先来看看全球金融体系的水有多深!

美国对外总欠债39万亿美元,对外总资产28万亿美元,资不抵债11万亿美元。见附件2 《美国国际投资头寸表》欧元区总资产28万亿欧元,总负债也是28万亿欧元。见附件3 《欧元区国际投资头寸表》欧美两个经济体的国民总收入才32万亿美元。假如美元有赖债的信号,欧美华尔街掌管的超过70万亿美元的金融资产就全部暴露在风险之下,可以想象的场景:美元的卖压会像洪水一样涌出,瞬间冲垮全球金融体系。美元赖债给全球金融体系带来的冲击和雷曼倒闭相比真的是小巫见大巫。如果美元赖债,灾难将堪比任何一次世界大战的后果届时欧美银行将全部破产。所以,说美国赖债容易,在实际操作层面几乎是不可实现的。

公众根深蒂固的另一个观点是:美国不能赖债,那就开动印钞机呗!

 (四)美国无法印钞还债

尽管美国欠的是美元本币债,但如果美联储开动印钞机还债,债权国还是要卖出美元的。比如说,美联储印钞还债给中国,美联储买入美债,中国卖出美债,体现在外汇交易上,就是中国卖出1万亿美元买入等值其它货币。这时问题就来了,中国卖出美元,谁来买入美元?如果美联储买入美元,美联储卖出什么货币?美国的外汇储备几乎是零,美联储无法卖出一个自己没有的非美元货币,对不对?看:国际收支原理就这么简单!美联储没有任何外汇储备,当他国卖出美元的时候,美联储根本无法干预汇市!无法干预汇市,市场卖出的美元就找不到买家;找不到美元的买家,美元汇率不就崩盘了吗?这就是为什么我总是说,美元没有任何自我保护力,美元是不折不扣的裸奔。美元稳定与否完全取决于国际债权人对美元的信心,信心崩塌时,除了债权人,上帝也帮不了美国。

(五)美元是美国优势也是美国软肋

优势:因为美元是国际结算货币,美国企业布局全球产业链,用美元借债,经营进出口贸易都没有汇率波动的风险,没有汇率风险,企业在全球竞争中就有10%左右的利润率优势。10%的竞争优势是决定性的赢家优势!所以美国企业比欧洲、日本、中国的利润高,竞争力强,美元是国际结算货币功不可没!


劣势:美国是长期逆差国,对外总债务达39万亿美元,其中22万亿美元在债券、基金和股票市场融资,在正常的市场环境下,美国金融市场的流动性很好,但是一旦市场走单边行情,市场流动性将一夜之间完全消失。2008年雷曼倒闭已经完美演绎了市场流动性是多么不堪一击!当美元危机到来时,没有任何力量可以挽救市场!所以,认为美元有效运作的前提是美元有足够的流动性,这个假设建立在美元市场不会有单边行情发生的前提下。当单边行情到来时,美元没有任何自我保护工具!美元的设计就是不折不扣的裸奔!美国11万亿的巨额净外债是美国国家经济安全的最大软肋!

现行的美元体系和特里芬悖论都是基于浮动汇率体系的经济学理论,过去60年的实践证明,浮动汇率体系过于简单粗暴的经济模型,在实践上是完全行不通的!

() 为什么浮动汇率体系必然失败?

其一:从浮动汇率本身来说:一国建立工业产业链其周期较长,一般需要5-10年左右。而浮动汇率的运行周期越来越短,越来越不可预测,浮动汇率已经失去了贸易不平衡的调节器作用。而且进出口竞争力是众多因素构成的,仅仅依靠汇率定价的改变是无法实现贸易再平衡的。

比如说,看人民币汇率定价是高估还是低估?如果你看房价,人民币就是高估,如果看基层劳动者的工资和他们赖以生存的基本物价,人民币就有很大的升值空间。还有,一个国家的福利制度也是影响其国际竞争力的原因。比如说美国人均收入4万美元,但4万美元收入的美国人,其生活质量并不比2万美元收入的意大利和西班牙人好。这是因为美国人承担的教育、医疗、城市管理费用很高,美国人的基本生活成本是全球最高的。这些因素都影响了一个国家在全球的竞争力。

其二:从全球主要国家如何应对浮动汇率体系弊端的角度来说:

简单粗暴的西方经济学认为通过汇率浮动就可以调节贸易平衡。于是,西方经济学关于国际贸易收支平衡原理的公式如下:

经常项余额=金融项余额

贸易顺差国中国和日本等亚洲各国为了维护本国再生产的持续进行,都采取了应对措施,即国家收储外汇储备,德国则是不惜代价的整合了欧元区。其目的都是帮助货币市场实现货币交易的均衡。于是国际收支平衡公式就演变为:
经常项余额=金融项余额+外汇储备

外汇储备帮助贸易顺差国平衡了外汇交易,稳定了再生产的持续进行,同时,也彻底摧毁了西方经济学家设计的幼稚的浮动汇率体系对国际贸易再平衡的调节作用。

美国经常用汇率操纵大棒来打压贸易顺差国,其实汇率操纵就是一个伪命题!全球外汇储备11万亿美元都是政府干预汇率的结果!没有政府干预汇市就没有外汇储备!而全球外汇储备11万亿美元,美国的净外债也是11万亿美元,这就是说美国就是靠全球的外汇储备来供养的。因为有外汇储备,美国才能维系其生存。没有全球外汇储备,美元早就崩盘了。

全球外汇储备是美元这个债王至今还没有爆仓的重要稳定因素,所以,我们设计新的国际贸易货币体系必须破解特里芬悖论。

  () 离岸货币独立运行才能破解特里芬悖论!

现行国际货币体系还是易货贸易的变种,无论奉行市场决定汇率的欧美,还是干预汇市的中国和日本,以及为多边自由贸易体系建立的WTO,迄今为止,全世界经济学家都没有解决贸易不平衡的清算问题。贸易顺差国无法实现对贸易逆差国的实际清算。实践中,贸易平衡是个别的,贸易不平衡是普遍的。在多边贸易体系下,这个问题就变得更加复杂。

美元的外债问题像全球金融体系的吸血鬼,不仅摧毁了美国的国家经济安全,同时也是全球金融安全的最大隐患。经济全球化走了300年,不管是黄金白银还是今天的美元做结算货币,都没有解决贸易不平衡的清算难题。回顾历次重大金融危机,其背后的原因都和贸易不平衡问题有关。英国等西方列强对大清王朝发动鸦片战争的经济动因也是英国对清朝的贸易逆差。逆差国的黄金白银流向了顺差国,从而导致逆差国黄金白银枯竭。

1971年美元摆脱了黄金束缚,但是依然无法摆脱国际收支平衡原理的约束,美国有多少逆差就积累了多少外债。国际贸易新货币体系必须化解这300年没有解决的难题。我的解决方案就是:在岸货币和离岸货币要完全独立运行。离岸货币不参与国内货币流转,只有这样,才能避免美元困境再次上演,从而破解顺差国不能管理全球储备货币的所谓“悖论”!

(八)设计全新的国际储备货币体系

美元体系的问题,简单讲是两大根本点:

1)资不抵债,庞氏骗局
2)经济学理论上的障碍,经济学家走不出特里芬悖论的陷阱

人民币国际化推动了近10年,规模仍然上不去,因为我们没有找到破解特里芬悖论的钥匙!破解特里芬悖论的秘密就是:在岸货币和离岸货币完全分离运行。

解决美元的的问题,新货币体系就必须反美元之道而行。货币经营权从美国这个债王让渡到外汇储备国,用全球外汇储备为全球清算货币背书。全球外汇储备60%来自亚洲,34%来自大中华经济圈,17%来自原材料供应国。8.3%来自石油供应国。仔细分析这些贸易顺差来源,85%的外汇储备的出口需求都来自中国,(见附件4《全球外汇储备分布》)。从2000年到2018年,中国对原材料国家和高科技产品供应国累积贸易逆差8万亿美元(见附件5《中国进出口贸易》)也就是说,对华贸易顺差国从中国赚了外汇,然后把外汇存到了美元。而中国的外汇储备又来自对美国的贸易顺差。可以这样说,目前中国和日本以外的外汇储备绝大多数是中国购买力贡献的。因此,所谓的石油美元并不成立,美元根本不是什么石油美元,而是人民币美元。中国完全有能力联合这些外汇储备国共同商讨全球去美元大计。


我称全新的国际结算和储备货币为“世界人民元”。“世界人民元”取义全球储备货币的主权属于世界人民!以下简称世界元。世界元是独立于任何一个国家货币之外的货币。建立“世界元”央行,储备货币国可以注入其外汇储备资产来参股,根据注入的资产规模来决定其在世界元央行的投票权和股份权益。世界元不是任何国家的国内清算货币,这才能从技术上解决顺差国无法管理国际储备货币的难题。这时有人会说,搞独立非主权国货币,特别提款权不是被空中楼阁了吗?特别提款权无法落地就是因为特别提款权和全球贸易无关,其功能先天不足。国际清算货币必须为贸易服务才有根基,特别提款权脱离了贸易,自然无法落地。

理解未来的新货币体系,简单讲,世界元将替代美元来承担国际贸易清算和国际信贷职能,世界元将成为全球外汇储备的蓄水池。世界元由外汇储备背书,没有印钞权,从事国际信贷业务就像任何一间商业银行一样量入为出。世界元利用信贷杠杆,发放信贷给一带一路,信贷目的是用于支持经济成长,促进贸易再平衡,而不是去填美国的消费债黑洞。这就从根本上解决了贸易不平衡的清算问题,也资助了欠发达国家的经济成长。

世界元技术上的操作,我初步设想,初期由离岸人民币先试先行,我用区块链原理,用真实的贸易和信贷数字做了实盘推演,技术上100%可以通过。离岸人民币完全可以率先数字化,并与在岸人民币完全隔离运行!成为全世界第一个区块链管理下的无纸货币。先用离岸人民币逐步去美元,当离岸人民币运行完善了,再引入亚洲和中东股东,过渡到终极方案——世界人民元,

世界元完全解决了经济全球化300年没解决的清算问题!有了国际贸易新货币体系,当我们成功去美元后,全球外汇储备才能普惠世界人民,同时给外汇储备国带来长期稳定的存款收益!

但是,美国的总负债达39万亿美元,总资产达28万亿美元,美元这么大的金融规模,我们如何去美元?其实也不难。简单说,去美元的过程就是非美国家去美元债的过程。

()去美元就是去非美国家美元债

如何去美元,首先要看世界各国为什么要储备美元?美元的需求分主动需求和被动需求。

主动需求,一些美国以外的国家和企业以发行美元债的方式来融资,为了保证还债的流动性需要,这些企业和国家自然要储备一定数量的美元以应不时之需。有的国家即便没有贸易顺差也干预汇市、储备美元,如印度。

被动需求:贸易顺差国和金融项顺差国为了平衡本国货币和外币之间的买卖而被动储备美元。贸易顺差国如中国、日本、韩国、新加坡、中东、巴西,金融资本流入顺差国如瑞士。这些国家储备美元完全是被动的,顺差国如果不储备美元,其本币将无限升值,本币无限升值将导致本国再生产活动无法正常运行。

去美元的难点在于如何保证汇率的相对稳定,如何从技术上避免断崖式货币危机。去美元真的不难,去美元,从去美元债开始!即先去掉对美元的主动需求,再减少对美元的被动需求。在实践操作上先减少非美国家和企业的美元债,然后为了平衡汇率的稳定,再被动减少美元的外汇储备。减少美元的主动需求和被动需求,正好是一个组合拳!

*举例来说:阿根廷发债借入世界元5亿元,发债目是用来归还以美元计价的外债。阿根廷得到5亿世界元后,卖出世界元,买入等量美元,阿根廷才有美元去归还以美元计价的债券。这时,外汇交易的平衡问题就来了,阿根廷卖出了世界元,谁来买入呢?世界元央行拥有大量的美元储备,可以立即卖出美元,买入世界元,从而达到美元和世界元的买卖平衡。这就是说,非美国家主动来减少以美元计价的外债,世界元被动卖出美元储备,以平衡外汇交易。这就是去美元的过程。去美元的过程也就是美元缩表的过程。全球外汇储备11万亿美元,全球非美国家以美元计价的外债也是11万亿美元,数字上主动需求和被动需求是基本平衡的,所以去美元外债不存在技术障碍。世界元央行掌管着全球外汇储备,央行完全有能力稳定世界元的汇率。而且在区块链管理下的世界元,一切公开透明,市场很容易被掌控的。世界元替代美元国际结算和储备货币的角色完全行得通。

世界元由顺差国主导管理,全球金融体系才能长治久安!顺差国主导国际储备货币也根绝了中国政府在人民币国际化的路上会重蹈美元覆辙。世界元的设计理念是顺差国王权!世界必须认清由全球债王主导的国际贸易货币体系的致命危险!有了世界元的世界,人类命运共同体才算真正上路!

全球外汇储备见顶,美国的贸易逆差继续累计,这是美元走到尽头的信号

国际收支平衡公式:

经常项余额=金融项余额+外汇储备

金融资本流入美元是不稳定的资金来源,而外汇储备的不断增加才是美元稳定的基石。2007年美国的净外债占全球外汇储备的19%,而今天已经达到了93%。(附件6《全球外汇储备vs美国净外债》2007年以来,全球外汇储备的持续增长是美元得以生存的供养脐带。现在,全球外汇储备见顶,美国外债不见顶,(附件7 美债vs全球外汇储备)美元的供养来源出了问题,美元已经无法依赖全球热钱来维系美元稳定,美元即将面临资金链断裂的风险!

美元到了最危急的时刻,无论中国是不是准备好了,我们都必须着手思考后美元时代怎么办?必须考虑如何为美元收拾残局了!没有时间了,我们必须做好准备!

中华民族伟大复兴的最大阻碍来自美国,而美元是最大的拦路虎。美元一旦失去信用,美国的军事实力和科技实力都将成为无水之源、无本之木。砍掉美国这个大旗, 台湾香港问题根本都不是问题!砍倒了美元这个大旗,西方经济学才能现出可笑幼稚的原形。我们才能在世界上真正拥有话语权!美元问题是世界经济的毒瘤,摘掉这个毒瘤,中国才能为全球化续命,为人类命运共同体铺路!期望中央能早做打算!

以上是我长期研究的核心观点。期待领导和专家的批评指正!

马霞

2020年2月5日 文字编辑:崔杨

附件1: 美国《国家收支平衡表》

附件2 《美国国际投资头寸表》

附件3 《欧元区国际投资头寸表》

附件4《全球外汇储备分布》

附件5 《中国进出口国家分布》

附件6 全球外汇储备和美国净外债对比

附件7 美债vs全球外汇储备

The US Dollar’s Woes and the Global Yuan

I have been engaged in international trade and foreign exchange trading for 30 years and have been thinking about the technical obstacles of economic globalization at the international settlement level. The Balance of Payments rules that the trade surplus countries end up with debts of trade deficit countries, and under the multilateral free trade system, the international settlement has become extremely complicated.

The Balance of Payments Principle:

Current Account Balance = Financial Account Balance + Foreign Exchange Reserves

The Balance of Payments Principle determines that if the left side of the equation is deficit, the right side of the equation will be external debt. If the left side of the equation is surplus, the right of the equation will be international financial claims. Deficit countries usually fail to settle the debt owed to surplus countries. Regardless of whether the US dollar is an international settlement currency or Renminbi is not a free flowing currency, the Balance of Payments always applies. International trade is settled twice, first between traders, then the currency conversion between countries. Even if the United States trade in dollar, its external debt is still a foreign debt, and the US Dollar, while enjoying the status of an international settlement currency, cannot escape the rule of Balance of Payments. That’s why Buffett said: With long-term persistent trade deficit, the United States will eventually become a colony of the creditors!

This is a problem Western economics has not solved in 300 years. Three years ago, I finally came upon a solution entirely from the technical perspective. Gaming with real data of 2017, it worked. Addressing the dollar dilemma, I hope my work will lead to the establishment of a new world trade currency system step by step.

(1) The Dollar Dilemma

Assessing whether the US-led globalization and the dollar system they designed is good or bad for the US, we need to start from the “Balance of Payments” (see Annex 1: U.S. Balance of Payments)

The Balance of Payments Principle:

Current account balance = Financial account balance + Foreign exchange reserve

From 1960, the United States has built a cumulative trade and service deficit of US $ 11.5 trillion, with a net international investment income of US $ 3.27 trillion, and personal remittance + government international expenditure of US $ 2.37 trillion. This means, in the past 59 years, the cumulative global profit return of American companies minus the return of profit to foreign investors, has resulted in a total net profit of 3.27 trillion US dollars. This income minus the personal remittance + government’s overseas expenditure of 2.37 trillion US dollars amounted to non-trade net income of 900 billion US dollars. This 900 billion income is not even close to trade off the 11.5 trillion trade deficit. Therefore, the entire nation’s running depends on increasing foreign debt. The cumulative increase in external debt is $ 11 trillion over the past 59 years! The public generally believes that although the United States has deficit in trade, American companies have made a fortune in globalization. This statement has no fact support at all.

The fact is the US-run international monetary system, centered on the US dollar, is maintained by the United States’ increasing foreign debt. As of September 2019, the global foreign exchange reserves were US $ 11 trillion, and the US net foreign debt was also US $ 11 trillion. From a global perspective, the global foreign exchange reserves have filled the black hole of US debt.

Why is this obvious problem not ringing global alarm?  Because mainstream economists believe this is the basis of the Triffin Paradox.

(2) The Triffin Paradox

Mr. Triffin argues that external debt is a necessary condition for the dollar to become a reserve currency. Money flows freely around the world, and savings of trade surplus countries naturally go to trade deficit countries, because if surplus countries’ financial institutions don’t convert traders’ gained dollars to local currency, these traders will not be able to continue reproduction. Therefore, trade surplus countries become trade deficit countries’ creditors, while the latter accumulates foreign debt. Mr. Triffin argues that if reserve currency countries need to absorb global savings, it’s only natural that trade deficit countries’ currencies should become global reserve currencies because only these countries need to borrow debt. As a result, trade surplus countries such as China and Japan naturally cannot become reserve currency states. This is the so called the Triffin Paradox. Call it a paradox because everyone knows that logic doesn’t work. The international trade settlement is the core of international financial stability, and this settlement is based on a paradox! This cannot go on. Supported by this paradox, the US foreign debt has put US economy in great danger.

The public is not alarmed because people believe the US government could print money to pay off their foreign debt.

(3) The US. Cannot Print Money to Pay Off Its Foreign Debt

Can the U.S. really evade paying debts? Let’s take a look at how deep the liquidity of global financial system is.

The United States has $39 trillion external debt, $28 trillion total external assets, meaning $11 trillion deficit in International Investment Position. (See Annex 2: Table of U.S. International Investment Positions)The Eurozone has total assets of EUR 28 trillion and total liabilities of EUR 28 trillion.  (See Annex 3: Eurozone International Investment Position Table). The combined gross national income of these two economies is only $32 trillion. If there is any sign that US would default its debt, more than $70 trillion financial assets under the control of Wall Street in Europe and the US would be exposed to risk. The foreseeable scenario could be that the dollar’s selling pressure surging like a flood, tumbling the global financial system instantly. Comparing to the impact of dollar debt default on the global financial system, the collapse of Lehman would be less than nothing! The dollar debt default would be catastrophic while all the major European and American banks going bankrupt. So, it’s easy to say that the US can evade paying debts, while in practice, it’s not an option.

Another entrenched view of the public is that if the US cannot evade paying debts, it can start the money printing machine!

Although the US. owes US dollar debt, creditors still have to sell dollars if the Fed starts the money-printing machine to pay off its debt. For example, the Fed prints money to pay off its debt to China, the Fed buys US dollar debt, and China sells US. debt which is reflected in foreign exchange trading. China sells US $1 trillion to buy the equivalent of other currencies. The question is, China sells dollars, who is going to buy them? If the Fed buys dollars, what currency does the Fed sell? America’s foreign exchange reserves is almost zero, so the Fed can’t sell a non-dollar currency it doesn’t have, right? The Balance of Payments Rules!.It’s that simple!

The Fed doesn’t have any foreign exchange reserves, and when other countries sell dollars, the Fed simply can’t intervene in the foreign exchange market. Without intervention in the currency market, no dollar buyer can be found. That’s why I always say that the dollar has no self protection back up plan. The dollar stability depends entirely on international creditors’ confidence in dollar. When the market confidence vanishes, nobody can save dollar except for its creditors. The US Dollar is America’s strongest suit and its Achilles’ Heel.

Advantage: Because theUS dollar is the international settlement currency, American companies borrow in US. dollars, and run import and export without the risk of exchange rate fluctuation. Without exchange rate fluctuation risk, enterprises in the global competition has a profit margin of about 10%.  A competitive edge of 10% profit is decisive. Therefore, American companies are more profitable and more competitive than those of Europe, Japan and China. The US dollar being an international settlement currency is indispensable.
Weakness The US is a long-term deficit country with a total external debt of $39 trillion, of which $22 trillion is financed in bonds, funds and stock markets. Under normal market circumstances, America’s financial market liquidity is fine. However,once a unilateral market is in place, all the market liquidity will be gone over night. The collapse of Lehman in 2008 was a perfect example showing how vulnerable the market liquidity can be. When the dollar crisis comes, nothing can save the market. So the premise of dollar working effectively is that it always has enough liquidity, and this conclusion is based on the assumption that the dollar will not have a unilateral market. When the one-sided market comes, the dollar doesn’t have any self protection mechanism. America’s $11 trillion net foreign debt is the biggest threat to its national economic security.

(4) Why Does the Floating Exchange Rate System Inevitably Fail?

The current US Dollar system and the Triffin Paradox theory is based on the floating exchange rate system, and the past 60 years have proven that this system does not work.

First, it usually takes a country 5-10 years to establish an industrial chain, while the operating cycle of the floating exchange rate is getting shorter and more unpredictable. The floating exchange rate is losing the regulative power to balance trade. Moreover, the competitiveness of import and export is composed of many factors, and trade rebalance cannot be achieved by relying soly on exchange rate changes.

For example, to assess whether the RMB is overvalued or undervalued, if you look at property price, the Chinese Yuan is overvalued; if you look at the wages of ordinary workers and prices of basic necessities, the RMB has a big room for appreciation.  Moreover, a country’s welfare system is also a key factor affecting its international competitiveness. For example, an average American earns an annual income of $40,000, but his living quality is no better than an Italian or a Spanish earning $20,000. This is because Americans bear higher costs of education, health care, and urban management. America’s living cost is the highest in the world. These factors all have an impact on a country’s international competitiveness.

Second, how major economies deal with the flaw of the floating exchange rate puts us in a global perspective.

Western economists believe that trade imbalance can be regulated by exchange rate fluctuation, so their balance of payment equation is:

Current account balance = Financial account balance

In practice, Asian trade surplus countries such as China and Japan adopted countermeasures to maintain domestic reproduction by establishing the foreign exchange reserves, while Germany integrated the Eurozone at all costs. The goal was to help the currency market achieve equilibrium of currency transactions. Therefore, the Balance of Payments equation evolved to:

Current account balance = Financial account balance + Foreign exchange reserves

The foreign exchange reserves has helped trade surplus countries to balance the foreign exchange transactions and to stabilize reproduction. In the mean time, it has ruined the adjusting function of the floating exchange rate.

The United States often labels trade surplus countries as exchange rate manipulators, while in fact, it’s a complete pseudo proposition. The $11 trillion global foreign exchange reserves is indeed the result of government intervention. Without government intervention in the foreign exchange market, there will be no foreign exchange reserves at all. The global foreign exchange reserves is $11 trillion, America’s net foreign debt is $1.1 trillion, this shows that the US. economy relies on global foreign exchange reserves to move on. Without global foreign exchange reserves, the dollar may have collapsed long ago. Global foreign exchange reserves plays a vital role in dollar  stability. So we must crack the Triffin Paradox when we design the new international settlement currency system.

  (5) Triffin Paradox Can Only Be Solved with Offshore Currencies Operating Independently

The current international monetary system is still a variant of barter trade. Whether in Europe and the United States, which pursue market-determined exchange rates, or in China and Japan, which intervene in foreign exchange markets, or at WTO established for the multilateral free trade system, so far, economists around the world have not resolved the settlement problem arised from trade imbalance. Trade surplus countries cannot achieve actual settlement with trade deficit countries. In practice, trade balance is rare and trade imbalance is common. Under the multilateral trade system, this problem becomes more complicated.

The dollar’s external debt problem is not only US economy’s biggest threat, but also the biggest danger to global financial stability. The economic globalization has been undergoing for 300 years, and gold, silver or today’s dollar settlement currency all failed to solve the settlement problem resulted from trade imbalance. Looking back at the major financial crises, the reasons behind were always related to trade imbalance. The economic motive of the British and other Western powers launching the Opium War against the Qing Dynasty was also the British trade deficit with the Qing Dynasty. Deficit countries’ gold and silver went to surplus countries, which led to the depletion of gold and silver in deficit countries.

In 1971, the dollar got rid of the shackles of gold, but it’s still under the rule of Balance of Payments. The United States has accumulated as much foreign debt as trade deficit. The new monetary system of international trade must tackle this 300 year problem. My plan is: onshore and offshore currencies should run completely independent of each other.  The international settlement and reserve currency should not participate in the circulation of domestic currency. Only in this way, can we avoid the dollar dilemma, thus cracking the Triffin Paradox.

(6) The New International Reserve Currency System

To solve the dollar problem, the international reserve currency must be independent from any sovereign state currency, and the global foreign exchange reserves must endorse the global clearing currency. At present, 60% of the global foreign exchange reserves comes from Asia, of which 34% from the Greater China economic circle, and 17% comes from raw material suppliers, 8.3% comes from oil suppliers. A careful analysis of these trade surpluses shows that 85% of the export demand for foreign exchange reserves comes from China (see Annex 4: Global Foreign Exchange Reserve Distribution).   

From 2000 to  2018 , China accumulated a trade deficit of US$8 trillion with raw material countries and producers of high-tech products ( see Annex 5: China’s import and export trade ) , which means that countries with trade surpluse with China earned foreign exchange from China and deposited it mainly in US dollars.  China’s foreign exchange reserves also come from trade surplus with the United States.  In one word, the bulk of foreign exchange reserves outside China and Japan is contributed by China’s purchasing power. Therefore, the so-called petrol dollar is no longer true. Countries with foreign exchange reserves together should work out a plan for the new global trade settlement and reserve currency.

I name the new international settlement and reserve currency the Global Yuan, independent of any sovereign state currency. Founding states of the Global Yuan can join the new Global Yuan Central Bank with their foreign exchange reserves. Their respective investment will decide their voting power and equity interests. The Global Yuan is not any country’s domestic clearing currency. This can technically solve the problem that surplus countries cannot manage international reserve currencies. SDRs cannot be implemented because SDRs have nothing to do with global trade. The new international settlement currency can only take root when it serves world trade. The SDRs system must be reformed to attract countries with foreign exchange reserves to be share holders in the new central bank, so that the new currency could serve world trade.

In short, the Global Yuan will replace the US dollar to function as the international trade settlement currency and international credit, and the Global Yuan will become a pool of global foreign exchange reserves. The Global Yuan is endorsed by participating states’ foreign exchange reserves. It does not have the right to print money. It is like any commercial bank to make ends meet when it comes to international credit business. The Global Yuan Central Bank can use credit leverage to support economic growth and promote trade rebalance. This will fundamentally solve the settlement problem caused by trade imbalance, while boosting global economic growth.

The Global Yuan will put an end to the 300 year international settlement problem originated from economic globalization. With the new currency system for international trade, the global foreign exchange reserves will benefit the people of the world, and in the mean time, bring long-term stable return to participating countries and investors.

7With Global Foreign Fxchange Reserves Reaching Ceiling, the US Trade Deficit Keeps Growing , A Red Light for Dollar Indeed

Balance of Payments:

Current account balance = Financial account balance + foreign exchange reserves

Financial capital inflows into the dollar are unstable sources of funding and the rising foreign exchange reserves is the cornerstone of dollar stability. The U.S. net foreign debt accounted for 19% of global foreign exchange reserves in 2007, and today it’s 93%. (see Annex 6: Global Foreign Exchange Reserves vs. Net Foreign Debt of the United States).

Data shows that since 2007, the continued growth of global foreign exchange reserves has been the umbilical cord for US dollar. Now, the global foreign exchange reserves has reached ceiling, but the US foreign debt is still growing. (see Annex 7: U.S. debt vs global foreign exchange reserves) The Dollar can no longer rely on global foreign exchange reserves to maintain its stability. The US. dollar is about to face the risk of a broken capital supply chain! The world has to be prepared for the coming up dollar crisis.

Annex 1

Annex 2

Annex 3

Annex 4

Annex 5

Annex 6

Annex 7

CV of the Author

Born in June 1959 in Tianjin China, Margaret Ma volunteered to be a peasant in Inner Mongolia in1976. During her stay in the rural area, She read “On Capital” by Karl Marx. In 1977, she passed the national college entrance exam and studied in Inner Mongolia Food Institute, accounting major.

From 1980 to 1987, she worked in an agency under Tianjin Municipal Planning Committee, in charge of large state enterprises’ foreign exchange loans conversion to RMB through trade. In 1993, she quitted the job and began to do import and export of bulk commodities. In 2000, she immigrated to Australia and became an independent investor.

Persistent reflection on futures helped Margaret develop a keen insight in the basics of exchange rate fluctuation. Margaret is now studing Balance of Payments in hopes of providing technical support for the new world trade settlement currency system.

经济贸易全球化之零和游戏

今天我来说说为什么贸易顺差国和逆差国之间的关系是零和游戏,贸易顺差正,贸易逆差为负,顺差和逆差相加=0, 贸易顺差国的顺差部分转变为顺差国拥有逆差国的债权,逆差国则体现为对外欠债。在经济全球化的多边贸易体系下这个零和关系变得有点复杂,但是,还是能一窥真相。 比如说,2000年到2018年,美国累计经常项逆差10万亿美元,美国的对外净欠债也是10万亿美元。同样2000年到2018年中国累计经常项顺差3.3万亿美元,中国的外汇储备是3.1万亿美元。这样问题就来了,逆差国无限度的借债,先不论欠债国能不能还得起负债,那么顺差国是如何持续经营的呢?这一点非常重要,这是破解特里芬悖论的要点,下面我继续用故事来演绎国家之间是如何经营这个零和游戏游戏的。

假如中氏家族有四个兄弟,每个兄弟自己独立过日子,老爸主持着兄弟之间的公平竞争,老爸有印钞权。初期,贸易在四个兄弟之间进行。老大把面包卖给老二,老大的收入,就是老二的支出,老二必须卖出等值产品才能有钱购买老大的产品。兄弟之间,一方的收入就是另一方的支出,四个兄弟就这样互相交换,过着自给自足的生活,这个模型就是所谓的内需型经济。所以,当任何经济学家鼓吹内需型经济时我都会呵呵,人不得外财不富,国家也是这样,中国人民要过上全球最富足的生活绝对不能仅仅依赖内需,内需型经济就是四个兄弟之间的经济。要致富,就必须拥抱全球化。这就是为什么习主席提出了人类命运共同体的伟大愿景。

好了,我们回来继续讲故事,老爸期望家族更加富裕,多积累一些储蓄,就鼓励四个兄弟勤奋工作,把富余的产出卖给其他家族。于是,四个兄弟增加工作时间,加大产出,把富余的产品卖给了美氏家族。

交易的过程中,中氏家族卖给美氏家族5万元的产品,但是,美氏家族只有2万元的产品卖给中氏。美氏没有等值的收入,剩下的3万元自然也没钱给中家,于是兄弟们找到父亲说,这生意没法做了,我们卖给美氏5万,我们的成本就要4万,美氏欠我们3万,我们如何支付工资和原材料货款?

老爸想了一下,我可以印钞给四个兄弟,让老美欠我的钱好了。于是老爸把美家3万元的欠条买了过来,这3万就是外汇储备。就这样,老爸不停的把老美的欠条买过来,老爸印钞买借条,资金没成本,白白得到一笔欠条的利息,也不向老美催债。不仅中家族这样做,日家,欧家也用同样的方式把产品卖给美氏家族。大家也不向美氏逼债,就这样,美氏打出来的欠条越来越多。

到了2018年,美氏家族的对外欠债已经达到其总收入的50%。其中,欠中家的钱最多。这时候,中家的父亲感觉不对劲了,这样下去这些借条早晚会打水飘的。但是,美氏欠债太多了,中家担心卖出美债会导致美币崩盘。所以开始和其他家族商讨如何卖出美债又不至于导致美币崩溃。。。

以上故事就是我们现行贸易体系的清算难题。 全球外汇储备11万亿,美国的净外债是10万亿,证明了全球贸易不平衡问题本质上美国的长期逆差问题。 美国利用其美元储备地位的优势吸纳了全球的储蓄,世界人民的储蓄都填了美国的消费债。消费债不创造价值,美国债多了不愁,借新债还旧债,而且每年总债务继续以5000亿美元的速度每年递增,美元已经完全沦为了旁氏骗局。这么简单清晰的事实,经济学家们说什么呢?他们说“你这就外行了,这就是著名的“特里芬悖论”啊!正因为美国是贸易逆差国,美元愿意对外国承担负债,美元才能称为全球储备货币啊?正因为中国是贸易顺差国和外汇储备贡献国,所以,人民币永远也不可能成为全球储备货币!的”

我的天啊,西方经济学是我知道的最荒谬的学问,难道各国积累外汇储备是为了供美国消费的吗???特里芬悖论的核心,一个国际储备货币的前体条件竟然必须是一个全球债王???下一讲我来分析特里芬悖论。之前我是铺开货币问题的简单事实,现在精彩部分就要来了!设计全球新货币体系首先要破解特里芬悖论。破解了特里芬悖论人类命运共同体才能上路。

时间关系,今天先讲到这里,美元问题和我们每一个人息息相关,百年大变局,最要的就是货币的变局,预见货币大变局将怎样变是未来20年财富爆发的最大的机会,机会留给有准备的人,这就是这个系列讲座的初衷。坚持收听,你们一定会有所斩获。

谢谢大家的收听,我们下一讲再见

Zero sum game of economic and trade globalization

Today I will talk about why the relationship between a trade surplus country and a deficit country is a zero-sum game. The trade surplus is positive, the trade deficit is negative, the surplus and the deficit add up to zero. The surplus of the trade surplus country would turn into indebtedness owed by the trade deficit countries. Deficit countries manifest it as external debt. This zero-sum relationship has become a bit complicated under the economic globalization of the multilateral trading system, but the truth can still be glimpsed. For example, from 2000 to 2018, the United States had a cumulative current account deficit of $ 10 trillion, and the United States’ net external debt was also $ 10 trillion. Similarly, from 2000 to 2018, China’s cumulative current account surplus was US $ 3.3 trillion, and China’s foreign exchange reserves were US $ 3.1 trillion. So, the question arises: The deficit countries could borrow infinitely without limit. Regardless of whether the debtor countries can afford to repay their debts, how does the surplus countries continue to operate? This is very important. This is the key to cracking the Triffin paradox. Below I continue to use stories to explain how the zero-sum game is operated between countries.

Say if the Chinese family has four sons, each of them living independently, dad would preside over a fair competition between the brothers, and dad would have the right to print money. Initially, trade was between the four brothers.  The eldest son sells bread to the second son. The eldest son’s income is the second son’s spending.  The second son must sell the equivalent worth of products in order to have money to buy the eldest son’s products. Among brothers, one party’s income is the other’s expenditure, the four brothers exchange with each other, living a self-sufficient life, this model is the so-called domestic demand economy. Therefore, when any economist advocates a domestic demand-based economy, I will chuckle as people could not be rich without foreign wealth, and so is the country. The Chinese people must not rely solely on domestic demand in order to lead the world’s richest life. The domestic demand-based economy is like the four brothers’ economy. To become rich, we must embrace globalization. That is why President Xi put forward a great vision of a community of shared future for mankind.

Well, let’s get back to the story. Dad wishes the family to get richer and accumulate more savings. He encourages the four brothers to work harder and sell the surplus output to other families. As a result, the four brothers increased working hours, increased output, and sold the surplus products to the American family.

In the course of the transactions, the Chinese family sold 50,000 yuan of goods to the American family, but only 20,000 yuan of the goods sold to the Chinese family in return. Americans has no equivalent income, therefore unable to repay the remaining 30,000 yuan to the Chinese family. So, the brothers go to their father claiming that they could not do the business anymore.  “We sold to The American 50,000 yuan of goods with the cost amounted to 40,000 yuan. American owe us 30,000, how do we pay for the wages and raw materials?” 

Dad thought about it for a while. He figured out he could print money to the four brothers and let the Americans owed him money. So, dad bought the debt of 30,000 yuan, which became the foreign exchange reserve.  In this way, old dad kept on buying the American debt notes. As he printed money to buy the debt notes is virtually without cost, he earned interest instead. Therefore, no hurry to urge the American to repay the debts. Not only did the Chinese family do this, but the Japanese and The Europeans sold their goods in the same way to the American family as well. They also do not bother to force the American to repay their debts.  Just like this, the Americans ended up with more and more debts.

By 2018, the American family’s external debt had reached 50% of its total annual income. Among them, most money owed to the Chinese Family. At this time, the father of the Chinese family felt that something was wrong, sooner of later those debt notes would go bad. But the Americans owes too much debt, and the Chinese worry that selling them could lead to a collapse of the U.S. currency.  So, they began to discuss with other families how to sell the US debt without causing the US dollar to collapse. . ….  

The above story is the clearing problem of our current trading system. The global foreign exchange reserves are $1.1 trillion, and the net foreign debt of the United States is $10 trillion. It proves that the global trade imbalance is essentially coming from the long-term deficit of the United States. The United States has taken advantage of its dollar reserve status to absorb global savings. The savings of the world’s people have filled the US consumer debt. Consumer debt itself does not create value. US debt is more worrying. New debt is used to pay off old debt, and total debt continues to increase at a rate of 500 billion US dollars each year, the dollar has become a Ponzi scheme. With such a simple and clear truth, what do economists say? They say, “You are layman, this is the famous “Triffin Paradox”! Because the United States is a trade deficit country and the US dollar is willing to assume liabilities to foreign countries, can the US dollar be called a global reserve currency? It is because China is Trade surplus country and foreign exchange reserve contributor, so the RMB can never become a global reserve currency! “

My God! Western economics is the most ridiculous knowledge I know. Why would countries be accumulating foreign exchange reserves for the American consumption???  At the core of the Triffin paradox, must the precursor conditions of an international reserve currency be a global debt king??? In the next talk, let me analyze the Triffin paradox. In the past, I have rolled out the simple facts about currency issues, now the exciting part is coming! Designing a new global currency system begins with cracking the Triffin paradox. Only by breaking Triffin’s paradox can the community of human destiny move on ahead.

Time is up for this session. The dollar problem concerns all of us. Out of this centennial change, the most important one is the change of currency. Foreseeing correctly how this happen perhaps providing the biggest opportunity for wealth explosion in the next 20 years. This is my original aim for this series of lectures. Keep listening, and you will definitely gain something.

Thank you, see you next time.

November 1, 2019 Ma Xia

国际收支平衡原理

今天我来继续讲美元的发展史。从1944宣布美元与黄金挂钩到1971年黄金就遭到挤兑,布雷顿森林体系仅仅存活了27年就崩盘了,摆脱了黄金束缚的美元走上了债务膨胀的不归路。今天我继续用故事来演绎一下与黄金脱钩后的美元发生了什么?

我们把主要国家比喻成家族,分别是美族、欧族、中族、日族。美币尽管撕毁了和黄金挂钩的承诺,但美氏家族的经济实力很强大,又与欧族联盟,其他小族群没实力抗争,又想和美氏继续做生意,与黄金脱了钩的美币就继续在各族之间流通,储蓄。

时间到了80年代,日氏家族开始壮大,日氏卖给美氏的商品大大的超过了从美氏买入的商品,于是日氏家族囤积了大量美币,日氏用卖货赚来的美币到美族人的地盘买房子买地。美族的自尊和元气大伤,于是美氏和欧氏联合施压日币升值,日币升值了,其商品的竞争力就掉了下来。日氏身单力薄,只能忍气吞声夹缝生存。这段时间,尽管各个族群之间也有很多贸易纷争,但是日子过得还算太平。

到了2000年,美氏的大麻烦来了,一向勤劳踏实,聪明又不爱惹事的中式家族加速崛起了,中式家族不仅勤劳肯干,还和美氏家族里最先先进的老板们合作办厂,美族人擅长科研开发,中族人务实肯干,且美族老板们掌握了大部分主动权,把脏活累活都丢给了中族人,自己还赚大头,何乐而不为呢?美族控制了产业链的设计端和消费端,中族负责生产,这就是美氏所称的微笑经营法则。

但是,微笑经营法则玩过了就变成了哭泣法则。一来二去,美族的工厂都迁到了外族的地盘,甚至连每天吃喝拉撒睡的必需品也要从其他族购买,除了中族人,还有其他家族也都愿意往美族人的底盘上卖货,美族人工资高,人也懒,没东西卖给其他族群,于是就不断的打欠条,债欠得越来越多。

以上故事诠释了国际贸易体系的模型,当今的国际贸易体系,实际仍然是易货贸易的变种,国际贸易到了结算层面,贸易顺差国拥有贸易逆差国的债权,顺差为正,逆差为负。 2000年到2018年,美国累计经常项逆差10万亿美元,美国的对外净欠债也是10万亿美元。请大家注意这个关键性的一点!美国的累计经常项逆差等于其对外净欠债,重要的话说三遍,美国的累计经常项逆差等于其对外净欠债美国的累计经常项逆差等于其对外净欠债,这就是国际收支平衡原理。一国积累了多少逆差,就积累了等值的外债。当我们理解美元寻求新货币体系出路的时候,我们必须牢记这个国际收支平衡原理。理解了这一点,其他问题就都迎刃而解。美国积累了长期贸易逆差,其美元自然流向贸易顺差国,从而导致美国对外债务不断的膨胀。说白了,国际贸易到了清算层面就是一个不折不扣的零和游戏。下一讲我来分析为什么是零和游戏。

时间关系,今天先讲到这里,美元问题和我们每一个人息息相关,百年大变局,最要的就是货币的变局,预见货币大变局将怎样变是未来20年财富爆发的最大的机会,机会留给有准备的人,这就是这个系列讲座的初衷。坚持收听,你们一定会有所斩获。

谢谢大家,我们下一讲再见

2019年11月9日马霞

The Principle of Balance of Payments

Today I’m going to continue with the history of the dollar.  From the announcement of the dollar’s peg to gold in 1944 to the run on gold in 1971, the Bretton Woods system collapsed after only 27 years of survival, and the dollar, free dwindled by gold, was on the road to debt inflation. Today, I continue to use the story to illustrate what happened to the dollar after the decoupling from gold.  

Let’s liken the main countries to families, namely, the American, the European, the Chinese, and the Japanese.  Despite tearing up the promise linked to gold, the American’s economic strength is very strong together with alliance of European Union, other small ethnic groups have no ability to fight against them, and thus want to continue to do business with the Americans.  The US dollar unpegged with gold continue to circulate and accumulate as savings among the various ethnic groups.

In the 80’s, the Japanese family began to grow. The products that Japanese sold to Americans greatly exceeded the products bought from Americans. Therefore, the Japanese family hoarded a large amount of US dollars. The Japanese used the money they earned to buy the houses and lands from the Americans.  The self-esteem and vitality of the Americans were severely damaged. Eventually the Americans and Europeans jointly pushed for the appreciation of the Japanese currency. As a result, the appreciated Japanese currency reduced the competitiveness of Japanese goods.  The single out Japanese could only endure the unfairness in order to survive.   During this period, despite many trade disputes between the various ethnic groups, life for the Japanese was relatively peaceful.

In 2000, American’s big trouble came, and the Chinese family, which has always been hard-working, smart and not prone to troubles, accelerated to rise. The Chinese family not only worked hard, but also cooperated with the most advanced American bosses to set up factories. The Americans are good at scientific research and development. The Chinese people are pragmatic and hard working. The American bosses have mastered most of the initiative and gave the dirty work to the Chinese people. They still make most of the profit. Why not? The Americans control the design and consumer ends of the industrial chain, and the Chinese are responsible for production. This is what the Americans calls the smiling business rule.

However, after playing with the smiling business rule, it becomes the rule of crying. One after another, the American factories have moved to the territory of the foreigners, and even all the necessities of daily life must be purchased from other ethnic groups. In addition to the Chinese, other families are also willing to sell goods to the Americans’ chassis. As the Americans have high wages, and people are lazy, they have nothing to sell to other ethnic groups, so they continue to raise debts and owe more and more debts.

The above story illustrates the model of the international trading system. The current international trading system is actually still a variant of barter trade. When the international trade has reached the settlement level, the trade surplus country owns the debt of the trade deficit country, the surplus is positive, and the deficit is negative. Between 2000 and 2018, the U.S. accumulated a current account deficit of $10 trillion, and the U.S. net external debt was $10 trillion.  Please pay attention to this critical phenomenon!  The cumulative current account deficit of the United States is equal to its net external debt.  Important words have to say three times: the cumulative current account deficit of the United States is equal to its net external debt; the cumulative current account deficit of the United States is equal to its net external debt. This is the principle of balance of payments.  How much deficit a country has accumulated, it would accumulate an equivalent amount of foreign debt. While we are trying to understand the problem of the dollar and looking for a way out for the new monetary system, we must keep this principle of balance of payments in mind. With this in mind, all other problems could be solved.  The United States has accumulated a long-term trade deficit, and its dollars naturally flow to the trade surplus countries, leading to the constant expansion of U.S. external debt.  To put it bluntly, when international trade has reached the settlement level, it undoubtedly becomes a zero-sum game.  Let me analyze why it is a zero-sum game in next talk.

Time is up for this session. The dollar problem concerns all of us. Out of this centennial change, the most important one is the change of currency. Foreseeing correctly how this happen perhaps providing the biggest opportunity for wealth explosion in the next 20 years. This is my original aim for this series of lectures. Keep listening, and you will definitely gain something.

Thank you, see you next time
 
Ma Xia on November 9, 2019.

美国或逐步走向被再殖民的深渊

开讲前先介绍一下我自己,我直接和间接从事货币交易近30年,可以说全部财富的积累都和货币有关,30年如一日,我一直试图理解货币交易的本质,几年前,我终于在看似简单的数学原理和逻辑混乱的西方经济学的乱麻中找到了理解货币问题的密码。我相信我为人类命运共同体找到破解美元陷阱的出路。但是,到目前为止,我还没有看到这个设想被公众广泛认知。下面,我将用系列讲座的方式把美元的问题和我的破解方案分享给大家,我们一起去探寻,为中国和世界找到摆脱美元的陷阱的药方。这个课题很宏大,我们慢慢的来庖丁解牛。今天,我从巴菲特2003撰写的长文——《沉重的贸易赤字等于在出卖美国》说起,我们先来看看巴菲特是怎么说的:  

巴菲特这样形容到:

假设世界只有两个村庄,分别叫勤检村和浪费村,村民各自每天工作8个小时过着幸福而自足的生活。后来,勤俭村居民想拥有更多的储蓄,就每天工作16个小时,把另外8小时的劳动成果外销给邻居——浪费村。 浪费村听到了很开心,以后自己不用努力工作也可以获得食物啦。但天下没有免费的午餐,浪费村没有收入,拿什么来够买勤俭村的商品呢?勤俭村就要求浪费村发行债券来交换商品,浪费村欣然接受了。

不劳而获的日子当然轻松富足,但是债券也越发越多,多年后,勤俭村累积了大量的浪费村的债券。村里终于有人提醒大家,这样下去,我们的借的债不是要我们的子孙来还吗? 我们要吃饭,又要偿还巨额债务,还债的时候我们不是要加倍的工作吗?不幸的是村里没人理会。

而另一方面,勤俭村也开始担心邻村能否兑现这些债券,于是改变了策略,他们把大部份债券卖回给浪费村换取货币,买下了浪费村大量土地,工厂和建筑。慢慢地,勤俭村买下了浪费村所有有价值的资产,浪费村没有任何资产可以变卖了,于是,整条村轮为勤俭村的殖民地。

这就是巴菲特对美国当下处境和未来命运的如实描述。 巴菲特的警醒在2003年,而过去的16年是美国对外欠债加速膨胀的16年,2003年美国对外总负债11万亿,净负债2.3万亿美元,到了2018年,美国对总负债达35万亿美元,相当于其国民总收入的166%,外净负债达到了10万亿美元,相当于国民总收入的50%。净负债10万亿美元对应全球外汇储备11万亿美元,这就是说,全球外汇储蓄已经被美国消费光啦!美元经营的这个全球储备银行已经实质破产了!!也就是说我们的3万亿外汇储备都已经打水漂了! 美国的外债问题已经到了无以复加的地步!可以肯定的说,美元迟早谢幕,中国必须取而代之。建立新的货币体系我们绝对不能复制美元典当国家的老路,这就是我想和大家一起共同探讨问题,寻求解决问的方案。。。

好,今天先讲到这里,美元问题和我们每一个人有关,美元崩盘了,全球金融体系也将崩塌,经济全球化,我们每一个人都被绑在全球化的战车上,正确的认识美元,清晰的认识到百年大变局如何变,我们不仅仅可以免受美元崩溃中所带来的财富损失,我们还可以在这场大变局中大赚特赚。这就是为什么我要开办这个系列讲座。谢谢大家的收听。下一讲我们再见。

2019年11月4日 马霞

The United States may gradually move towards the abyss of recolonization

Thank you host. Firstly, I want to introduce myself. I have directly and indirectly engaged in currency trading for nearly 30 years. I can say that most of my wealth accumulation is related to currency, During the last 30 years, I have been trying to understand the nature of currency trading every day.  A few years ago, I finally found a code to understand the currency problem in the mess of seemingly simple mathematical principles and logical confusion in Western economics. I believe I find a way to crack the dollar trap for the Community of Destiny for Humanity. But so far, I have not seen this idea widely recognized by the public. Below, I’ll share my view on the dollar problem and my cracking plan with a series of lectures, and we’ll explore ways to get rid of the dollar trap for China and the rest of the world. This is a very grand subject. We will explore it in different pieces with a kind of magical skilled craftsmanship just like the cook Ding. Today, I’m going to take a look at what Warren Buffett said, starting with Buffett’s 2003 essay, ” America’s Growing Trade Deficit Is Selling the Nation Out from Under Us:”

Buffett put it this way:

Assuming that there are only two villages in the world, called the thrifty village and the waste village, the villagers each work eight hours a day to live a happy and self-sufficient life. Later, the residents of the thrifty village wanted to have more savings, working 16 hours a day and exporting another eight hours of labor to their neighbors the waste village. Waste village was very happy to take it. Now they do not have to work hard to get food and goods. However, there is no free lunch.  Waste village never produce enough income to buy goods from thrifty village. Therefore, the village of thrifty demands the waste village to issue bonds in exchange for goods, and the waste village readily accepts it. The waste village gets what they want without working hard, but the bonds being issue is getting more and more. As time goes by, the thrifty village have accumulated substantial amount of waste village bonds. Some people in waste village finally realize that if the situation goes on, they would leave their children with huge amount of debt to repay in the future. Don’t we have to double our work while we must earn our living and repay the huge debts? Unfortunately, the waste village just ignore the fact. On the other hand, the thrifty village begin to worry about whether the neighboring villages could honor the bonds, so they change their tactics, selling most of the bonds back to the waste village for money and buying the waste village’s vast amounts of land, factories and buildings. Gradually, the village bought all the valuable assets of the waste village until they do not have any more assets to sell, so the whole village becoming the colony of thrifty village. This is Buffett’s true description of America’s current situation and future destiny. Buffett’s wake-up call was in 2003, and since then America’s external debt have been accelerated rapidly. The U.S. total foreign debt was $11 trillion and net debt of $2.3 trillion in 2003, and by 2018, the U.S. total debt amounted to $35 trillion, or 166 percent of its gross national income. Net external debt amounted to $10 trillion, equivalent to 50 per cent of gross national income. Net debt of $10 trillion corresponds to $11 trillion in global foreign exchange reserves, which means that the global foreign exchange savings have been consumed by the United States! The global reserve bank, run by the dollar, is essentially bankrupt!! That meant our 3 trillion-dollar foreign exchange reserves have been watered down! America’s external debt problem has reached the point where it cannot sustain! To be sure, sooner or later, China must replace US. The establishment of a new monetary system should not replicate the old way of the dollar pawn country. This is what I want to work with you to explore the issues, to find a solution to the problem …

Well, let’s start from here today. The dollar problem concerns all of us. I believe when the dollar collapses, the global financial system will collapse as well. The globalization that each of us tied to is a global chariot. It is important to have a correct understanding of the dollar, a clear understanding of how the great changes of the century would take place. Not only can we avoid suffering from loss of wealth caused by such collapse but also make good money out of this big move. That’s why I’m running this lecture series. Thank you for listening. Let’s see you again soon.

November 4, 2019 Ma Xia

关于我自己

今天开始我的专题讲座,

我有30年的货币交易经验和市场交易经验,作为独立投资人,我对全球数字如数家珍,一直看全球基本经济数字,一直不断的思考,我觉得人类有一个无解的难题,就是贸易不平衡所带来的清算难题,这个问题就体现在一个国家的国际收支能力上。 一个国家的国际收支能力决定了一个国家能不能印钞,决定了一个国家的财政政策。我想从技术角度谈国际收支和货币问题,让大家看见現行货币体系的问题,从而找到解决问题的答案。

通过 WordPress.com 设计一个这样的站点
从这里开始